Sunset Beach, Shelter Island Heights - Reviews, Room Options & Prices 2025

Book and save

up to 10%

compared to Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States, 11965

Sunset Beach, a 4-star romantic seaside hideaway, sits on Shelter Island's most idyllic beach, offering pet-friendly accommodations with grooming services.

Bay View Rooms

Modern rooms at Sunset Beach feature hardwood floors, glass-topped tables, and private terraces with bay views. Each accommodation includes flat-screen LCD TVs, iPod docking stations, and free Wi-Fi.

French Dining Experience

The Sunset Beach Restaurant and Bar serves French cuisine in a casual atmosphere, complemented by a comprehensive wine list and full-service bar.

Beach and Recreation

Guests can access a private beach and explore the island with complimentary bicycle rentals. The property offers yoga sessions and in-room massages.

Transport and Access

Located 52.5 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport, the hotel is accessible via ferry service from both Greenport's North Fork and Sag Harbor's South Fork. Check-in time is 4 PM, with check-out at 11 AM.

“Sunset Beach offers fine views and a laid-back vibe!”view full review

View hotel on map

“Absolutely loved the beautiful views and relaxing atmosphere!” view full review

Check-in/Check-out

from 16:00-23:59

until 11 am

Amenities

Public parking is possible on site for free.

Wireless internet is available in the entire hotel for free.

Other information

A full breakfast is served and charges are applicable.

One child: 0 - 2 years

Cot: FREE

Existing beds: FREE

One child: 3 - 17 years

Existing beds: FREE

Extra bed: us$ 100

Children above
17 years or adults:

Extra bed: us$ 100

Pets are allowed on request.

Year renovated:2010

Number of rooms:20

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

King Room

Max:

2 persons

42 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Balcony

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Double Room Two Double Beds

Max:

2 persons

42 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Balcony

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Deluxe King Room

Max:

2 persons

45 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A guide to all available transportation options

City Centre

Shelter Island Heights100 m

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 84.4 km

Republic (FRG) 113.0 km

Facilities

Experience a variety of amenities at the boutique hotel, crafted to ensure your comfort and unforgettable moments

Charming Restaurant Experience

“I had a good experience at the restaurant, which offers a blend of French-American cuisine. We enjoyed the ambiance and the fresh food, especially the warm artichoke and Basque cheese. Although we experienced a hiccup with our reservation, the hostess was very accommodating, ensuring we were taken care of.” view full review

Quirky Charm

“While the bathroom could use some updates, it adds to the overall character of the stay. The vintage design brought a certain nostalgic charm, though it did remind me of simpler accommodations. Just keep in mind that it leans to the rustic side—perfect for those who appreciate a more laid-back vibe!” view full review

Comfort with Character

“The room we stayed in had a unique mix of rustic decor with plain comforts that felt homey. Despite being basic, the view of the bay made waking up a pleasure. It’s not the fanciest accommodation, but the character of the room added to our overall experience on the island.” view full review

Fun Evening Vibes

“The evening atmosphere was vibrant, especially with the DJ playing music as the sun set over the beach. It was lively and perfect for socializing. I loved the unique vibes of the place; it's definitely a great spot for some fun, albeit a bit more party-centric during the weekends!” view full review

General

Wi-Fi
Smoke detectors

Dining

Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area

Room features

Dressing area
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Hair dryer

Media

Flat-screen TV
Direct dial telephone
CD player
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States, 11965

Map view

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States, 11965

City landmarks

Shelter Island Country Club

700 m

Golf Course

Shelter Island Golf Course

720 m

Shelter Island Tennis Club

900 m

Event hall

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

2.2 km

Church

Our Lady of the Isle Church

1.2 km

Dering Harbor Marina

2.3 km

Amusement Park

Greenport Antique Carousel

3.2 km

Island

Shelter Island

2.3 km

Sylvester Manor

2.2 km

440 4th St at the LIRR Tracks

Railroad Museum of Long Island

2.9 km

Wiggins St Greenport Commercial Pier

Fireboat Firefighter Museum

3.0 km

519 4th St

Congregation Tifereth Israel

3.0 km

Market

The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor

2.2 km

Front Street Mitchell Park

Camera Obscura

3.1 km

Museum

East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation

3.0 km

Church

Shelter Island Presbyterian Church

2.5 km

3rd St

East End Seaport Maritime Museum

3.5 km

Gallery

Nova Constellatio Gallery

3.4 km

Manhansett Chapel Museum

2.7 km

Harbour

Greenport

3.4 km

Fire Fighter Ship New York

2.9 km

Shelter Island Whale's Tail

2.8 km

Church

Saint Marys Episcopal Church

2.8 km

Long Island Train Museam

2.9 km

Greenport Theatre

3.1 km

Saint Agnes Roman Catholic Church

3.0 km

Museum

Havens House

3.1 km

Gallery

VSOP Art + Design Projects

3.1 km

Nearby

Sunset Beach

220 m

Beach

Crescent Beach

520 m

Restaurants

The Pridwin Restaurant

910 m

81 Shore Road

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

62%

enjoyed the hotel and would happily stay again

6.2/10

Nice

Rooms

5.4

Location

6.8

Service

6.0

Dining

5.0

United States, March 2025

6.6/10

My stay at Sunset Beach was a mixed bag. The location was stunning, providing beautiful beach views. but the service left much to be desired. The restaurant's limited hours and lack of breakfast options were frustrating, especially when my daughter and I were starving. While we appreciated the beach's ambiance and friendly staff, the overall condition of the rooms felt neglected, making it hard to justify the high price for what we received.

Rooms

5.0

The rooms felt a bit rustic and were not super luxe. definitely room for improvement. The rug was dirty and the refrigerator didn't work, which was disappointing.

Service

6.0

The staff were friendly, but there were notable issues. like the lack of breakfast and the restaurant being closed on Tuesdays. I did appreciate the manager's responsiveness when we needed food delivered, though.

Location

8.0

The natural beauty of the beach was wonderful and the atmosphere was relaxed. it was definitely a highlight of the stay.

Dining

5.0

Dining options were limited, with no breakfast service and the restaurant closed on certain days. The lunch provided by the manager was a nice gesture, but it shouldn't have to come to that.

Facilities

5.0

Facilities felt neglected, with dirty AC units and poor upkeep. the hotel certainly needs investment to enhance the experience.

Terry

United States, February 2025

5.0/10

My experience at Sunset Beach was a mixed bag. The beach and bar had a pleasant vibe that I enjoyed, but my night was marred by loud parties and poor service. While I appreciated the scenic beauty, the minimal room quality and high drink prices left me disappointed.

Rooms

5.0

The room I stayed in was quite minimal, lacking in comfort despite being clean. It felt more in disrepair than anything.

Service

5.0

The staff at the beach were friendly, which added to the overall experience. However, the restaurant service felt rushed and unenthusiastic, especially when considering the price of drinks.

Location

6.0

The scenic beauty of Shelter Island and the vibrant party atmosphere were definite highlights, making it a popular spot that feels lively and fun.

Dining

5.0

The dining experience was frustrating due to the confusion over reservations and the high prices for mediocre food and drinks. I expected more for the cost, especially after dealing with the parking situation.

Facilities

5.0

While the amenities looked appealing, they could not compensate for the chaotic atmosphere and my disappointing night.

Thomas

United States, January 2025

6.8/10

My stay at Sunset Beach was a mix of fun and frustration. The party atmosphere and beautiful beach definitely made for nice moments, especially as the sun set each evening. However, the service left much to be desired, and the accommodations felt more rustic than luxurious. While I appreciated the casual vibe, I couldn't overlook the lack of breakfast options and the restaurant's closures during my stay.

Rooms

6.0

The rooms were rustic and not overly luxurious, which was okay for me since I didn't plan to spend much time there, but definitely not what I expected for the price I paid.

Service

5.0

The staff had its ups and downs; the beach staff were friendly, but the front desk service was dismissive, and I experienced delays in getting assistance with food when the restaurant was closed.

Location

6.0

Sunset Beach is in an idyllic spot on Shelter Island, perfect for beach lovers, but accessibility was a bit tricky without transportation from the ferry.

Dining

5.0

Dining was a disappointment, with restaurant hours that didn’t align with our needs and limited breakfast options available, leaving us hungry more often than not.

Facilities

5.0

Facilities felt a bit neglected; while the beach was lovely, the overall upkeep of the hotel left a lot to be desired, especially for the price.

James

United States, December 2024

6.2/10

I had a mix of experiences at Sunset Beach. While the beach was lovely and the staff were friendly, the dining options left a lot to be desired, particularly the restaurant's limited hours. The overall ambiance felt relaxed, but the pricing was steep for what I received, leaving me unsure if it was worth returning. 🌊😅

Rooms

5.0

The rooms were rustic and comfortable, but not luxurious. I expected more for the price I'm paying.

Service

7.0

The manager was responsive to my complaints, particularly when it came to food delivery. The beach staff were also friendly, adding to my overall experience.

Location

6.0

The hotel is in a great spot near the beach, which I loved! However, getting around was a bit of a hassle without proper transport options.

Dining

5.0

Dining options were quite limited, especially with the restaurant closed for lunch on some days. Prices for drinks were excessive, which was disappointing.

Facilities

5.0

The ambiance was nice, especially on the beach, but the facilities felt somewhat underdeveloped for the rates charged.

Natalie

United States, December 2024

6.8/10

I had a mixed experience at Sunset Beach. While I loved the beautiful beach and the friendly staff, I found the facilities lacking and the dining options disappointing during my stay. The atmosphere was laid-back and my daughter enjoyed it, but some room improvements are definitely needed.

Rooms

6.0

My room was okay but nothing fancy. It felt a bit rustic and could use some upgrades.

Service

7.0

The manager was responsive to my concerns, arranging food delivery when the restaurant was closed. However, the initial check-in experience was not smooth.

Location

8.0

Shelter Island itself is stunning with scenic views, but it's essential to have transportation for exploring.

Dining

5.0

Dining was frustrating as the restaurant closes on Tuesdays and breakfast options were very limited. The manager did help by providing lunch later, which was a nice touch.

Facilities

5.0

The beach area was lovely, but the overall facilities felt minimal and the lack of breakfast as well as dining options on certain days was disappointing.